Does America Need A New New Deal?

Are there slices of American citizenry – tax payers, home owners, farmers, public school teachers – being held hostage by a social contract executed in the era of keeping the trains running on time? Considering the current need to make sure trains don’t derail and spill their toxic cargo into our water supply, it may be time to rethink our expectations of government and social responsibility. Not to ignore the existence of corruption back in the day of the robber baron, but there was a time when it was reasonable to expect a person’s word was their bond, and if they broke that bond, there were tangible consequences. Contrast that idea to current culture where a person’s word often isn’t worth a tweet.

As members of a society, we should be accountable for our actions. A public thrashing on social media is not the same as accountability. Neither is being a chronic victim or playing the blame game an appropriate substitute for personal responsibility. Here however, I am NOT talking about holding others accountable. I am talking about participating in society for the good of society. I am talking about responsible corporate citizenship. I am talking about engaged, effective civic leadership. I am also talking about the standard of conduct we should be able to expect from each other.

What is America’s social contract? I think it depends on who you ask. The inscription on the Statue of Liberty states American society is a refuge for tired and poor hungry masses of homeless, wretched refuse. Some might say that particular social contract does not make America the land of opportunity but instead, the land of prey for the opportunistic. As we see the homeless population increase, I think we can say mission accomplished.

Is this our collective shame or only the shame of those inclined to be ashamed of such things? I don’t know. What I do know is that in my city there are homes in foreclosure, sitting vacant less than one mile from houses being built on spec priced at half a million dollars a pop. How is this possible? Planning and zoning is asleep at the wheel. How is it possible that 10% of my city’s 50,000 residents live on one street? How is it possible that there is no public park within walking distance of that street? Still asleep. How is it possible that there is empty retail space a stone’s throw away from new construction of more commercial property? How is it possible we can turn a blind eye to red flags and then stand with our mouths gaping open when tragedy strikes? Strangely, when this happens we find ourselves sleeping with one eye open, if only for a little while.

What we have is a duct taped scrapbook of broken promises signed, sealed, and delivered to anyone who calls themselves an American whether or not they choose to practice good citizenship and a growing trend of tax payers wanting to keep more of what they earn from the fraud, waste, and abuse at the public trough. We are relying on a framework from a time period most Americans don’t know or care about. How we live, work, and communicate has changed significantly since Native Americans were forcibly removed from their homes, since westward expansion, since the underground railroad, since the horseless carriage became more than a passing fad, since indoor plumbing and electricity were included with the Sears and Roebuck construction kit, since the Civil Rights Movement, since Roe v. Wade, since the demise of the space program and the advent of smart phones. Yes, we have a long and rich history. So rich, in fact, we seem determined to keep repeating it.

The Trail of Tears,  by Robert Lindneux (1942)

The Trail of Tears, by Robert Lindneux (1942)

In addition to math and science, students were once taught that our social contract includes things all members of a society must do – work hard, help others, duck and cover – and some things members of a society should not do – take what doesn’t belong to us, deceive others for gain or pleasure, make the war of our parents the war of our children. This sounds like a good place to begin, but there’s more to a social contract. There’s always more, because if there is anything society likes to do, it’s complicate things, and in the process we can forget what we are trying  to accomplish. Some people remember the ever quoted, “Be fruitful and multiply.” In light of the some 7 billion people currently on the planet, rethinking that behavior might be worth a try.

How about: Have all the family you can personally afford to shelter, feed, clothe, and educate without mortgaging their future and wiping out every living organism on the planet in the process? Or how about: If a behavior occurs often enough to become a stereotype, it may be time to change the behavior.

In the year of the tax payer 2014, workers pay income taxes into the public coffers to maintain the systems upon which developed (and over-developed) society has become dependent. Businesses, large and small, from sea to polluted sea are agents of the federal government, required to withhold federal and state income taxes from its employees. If a business doesn’t want to withhold payroll taxes from its employees, it loses the license to do business or it outsources work to a developing country trying to make itself into a mini McMerica. Some workers live in states with no state income tax. Currently there are nine. Those states are Alaska, Texas, Nevada, Florida, South Dakota, New Hampshire, Tennessee, Washington, and Wyoming. Workers in those states get to keep more of their earnings, and for those who only have to work one job to make a living, all the better.

Of course, anyone who consumes anything pays sales tax. Sales taxes are also collected by businesses and generally go toward supporting infrastructure such as roads and bridges. Public schools are also funded by property taxes. Home owners whose property value is high but who don’t have school-aged children may, in some cases, pay more than people who have children but don’t own a home. Tax structure is complex, and not the subject of this post. Property value is based on many factors. Some of which are out of the home owner’s control, such as commercial over-development that chokes out neighborhoods, road and highway expansion that generates unwanted noise and congestion creating pockets of housing where no one wants to live.

Funding for public education in some urban areas, some rural areas, bankrupt cities, and communities with untaxable drug and weapons sales is a dingy tied to a sinking ship. Retaining, much less recruiting, talented professionals to teach the hundreds of thousands of children who live in these areas all across America is a pipe dream, nearly impossible, a daunting task. Some believe investing in public education for all children everywhere is a security measure that prevents criminal activity and therefore it is in everyone’s best interest. Others say private schools produce better results. One thing is for certain, some creative thinking is needed to come up with remedies for our failing education system.

Society is people living together in organized communities with shared laws, traditions, and values. We are currently bound by a social contract which not everyone believes they are obligated to honor. As we face the future trying to form a more sustainable union of the ever increasing population of diverse cultures that is this Great American Melting Pot, perhaps it is time to consider a new New Deal. But let’s call it something else. Remember what happened with New Coke.

This entry was posted in Observations and tagged , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

15 Responses to Does America Need A New New Deal?

  1. Lyle Krahn says:

    If we were starting a society from scratch today, it would be interesting what it would look like. Too bad we can’t do that every once in a while.

  2. This one took me a while, too. Only because I wanted to digest each and every word and let them all sink in.

    As somebody who lives in one of those income tax-free states, I can attest to the fact that the extra take-home pay makes a difference. It’s about 9%, no small number when you factor in a middle-class income. And I’m in a unique position because I can hop in my car and drive across the border of a sales tax-free state in less than 10 minutes. Many say living here is the best of both worlds. It’s hard not to agree.

    I’ve always been a huge fan of Roosevelt and the New Deal. He made life unimaginably better for the majority of Americans. But like you say, times have changed, and maybe we should consider a new New Deal. The problem is, with Congress so bipartisan these days, I don’t know that we could ever get both sides to work together and come up with a solution.

    Thoughtful, well-written post regardless.

    • Honie Briggs says:

      Mr. Petruska,
      I think you meant to say that Congress is partisan. For bipartisan means opposing sides work together to find common ground, and I don’t know when that has happened in my lifetime except for maybe when Congress votes to give themselves increased benefit at the expense of tax payers. It is an understandable mistake, as noisy rhetoric often blurs the context of words, distorting them to the point we no longer understand their meaning. This is what I call the Babel Effect. Media (all forms) has perfected the confounding of language with marvelously executed SPIN. Thank you for your thoughtful comment.

  3. Standing ovation. The social contract is broken, rewriting it is our duty yet we seem not to know how to begin. I see the same things you see, it makes me weep.

    • Honie Briggs says:

      Val, I think there are many people who do know how to begin. I think there are also people whose goal it is to create stumbling blocks for those willing to participate in civil public discourse that could lead to solutions. I think there are many people who understand the immediate needs in their communities and work together at the local level in women’s shelters, food pantries, and counseling/job training centers to provide for those in need. I think the best we can do is work with what we have in front of us because the scope of the world’s problems can overwhelm to such a degree as to stagnate genuine effort and paralyze meaningful intent. Just my thoughts. Thanks for your comment.

  4. Impower You says:

    Here here! Everyday I also walk by vacant storefronts and new commercial construction, abandoned homes and new residential construction and it boggles my mind. It’s as if we have no concept of sustaining our neighborhoods. It’s the same as thinking a fresh coat of paint can keep a wall standing. I am confounded.
    I am active in my community, and vote in presidential AND local elections because I can see that while my voice may be small it still carries weight. Social and governmental responsibility are not separate from individual empowerment. In fact I don’t see how you can have any without the others.

  5. acflory says:

    I’m Australian, so I can’t comment on the American situation, however I believe the malaise you talk about is spread all across the developed world. Perhaps we’ve all just become too soft, too self-centred. Or perhaps we’ve allowed the concept of Capitalism, with its inherent core of ‘me,me,me’ to displace the ideals of democracy. I don’t have any answers, but I suspect things will have to get a great deal worse before we wake up, and realise that our mutual survival depends not just on competition, but also /co-operation/. Those two ‘Cs’ have to be in balance if society is to become healthy again.

    • Honie Briggs says:

      Well, a comment on the American “situation” is a comment on the human condition no matter in which hemisphere we live. I’m always interested in the lines we draw to divide ourselves into “us” and “them”, like those nylon tapes at the airport that separate the platinum traveler from the rest of us riff-raff. No one likes to think about the fact that if the plane goes down, we will all feel the impact. You make an excellent point about our mutual survival. Thanks, Meeks.

  6. napperscompanion says:

    What a wonderful, thoughtful piece. This one took you a while! I wrote a blog post a while back that I think wrestles with some of the same challenges you articulate so well here. Please don’t feel obliged to read, but if you’re interested, here’s the link. http://anapperscompanion.com/?s=The+Monsters%2C+the+Lunatics%2C+and+Me&submit=Search

    Peace,
    John

    • Honie Briggs says:

      Peace to you too John. This post did take some thought. Although I’ve written quite a lot about my observations of the world and my own, however limited, experience within it. You know, the unexamined life not being worth living, and all. Someday maybe I will have more positive observations to share. Thank you for your comment.

Go Ahead, Make My Day!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s